Paper Evaluation Criteria

100 points—category point scale: 0-5

 

5: Excellent, flawless, flashes of brilliance throughout

4: Clearly above average, several flashes of brilliance

3: Satisfactory, no major problems, a few minor problems

2: below average, a few major or several minor problems

1: clearly not passing, several major and/or minor problems

0: Did not do

I will also give .5 gradations when appropriate

 

Categories for Evaluation

 

Organization & development (45)

___ Thesis

___ Introduction

___ Conclusion

___ Paragraphs, topic sentences, unity of ideas

___ Transitions

___ Argumentation: overall logical arrangement of ideas

___ Development / support: do you make connections / use plenty of examples?

___ Appropriate number and range of primary and/or secondary sources

___ All assignment components addressed

 

Grammar and other surface features (25)

___ Conciseness: get to the point, don’t use fillers such as “on account of the fact that”

___ Sentence structure: variety and clarity

___ Word choice: use language appropriate for a college level, academic essay

___ Punctuation

___ Editing: spelling, capitalization, etc.

 

MLA format & documentation (30)

___ Appropriate font size and type, correct margins, etc.

___ MLA Works Cited page

___ MLA in-text citations

___ Quote integration

___ Quote explication

___ Paraphrasing quotes