UNLV banner

Debra L. Martin, PhD
Associate Professor of Biological Anthropology


Writing Rubrics

Teachers can use rubrics like these to give students better feedback on their written work (drafts and final copies). Rubrics give students detailed feedback while minimizing the time the instructor has to spend writing comments. For each item, the instructor makes a check mark placing that student's work on the scale between "weak" and "strong." Add a few marginal comments and a few end-comments, and the students will have a clear sense of their strengths and weaknesses.

The check marks indicate where on a scale of weak-to-strong you are with particular research and writing skills.

Research and Writing Skills
Weak
OK
Strong
Content: substantive, synthetic under-examined
depth and critique
Organization: clarity, structure no organization
purposeful flow of ideas
Language: sentences, wording fragments/run-on sentences
skillful writing
Mechanics: spelling, grammar errors
no errors

punctuation, proofing mistakes

sloppy writing
perfect
Research References: citations secondary sources only
good mix

type of sources, biblio.

poor/no citation
proper referencing
Point of view: voice, analysis no position
developed, supporter position

supported by evidence

unsupported opinions
careful opinions
Professional: style, development informal, chatty
formal, precise

presentation

big words, esoteric jargon
clear language
Enjoyment: engagement with joyless presentation
compelling to read

reader, enthusiasm

boring
original, creative

Back to Pedagogy

© 2007 Debra L. Martin | Site Map