|
Executive MBA
EMBA 702
Law, Regulation and Ethical Issues
July-September 2006
2 Credit Hours
Professor: Robert J. Aalberts J.D., M.A
Department of Finance, College of Business
Office: Beam Hall Room 524 Office Phone: 895-3919 E-Mail: robert.aalberts@unlv.edu
Website: http://www.unlv.edu/faculty/aalberts
Through readings, class discussions, and a written assignment we will explore
legal, regulatory and ethical issues which affect managers in the practice
of business. Readings and lectures will provide students with a basic
background in the theoretical foundations and practical workings of the U.S.
legal and regulatory environment for business. The course will also
provide a basic grounding in the major ethical approaches developed through
the history of philosophy, and show how they relate to legal and regulatory
issues as they affect managers and business practitioners.
To accomplish these goals the course will delve into three main areas of
study. The first is a comparative presentation through lectures and readings
of the two main legal systems of the world, how they evolved and presently
work. In the second part we will read, discuss and critique the book A Civil
Action in order to gain an understand of the actual litigious environment
within which lawyers and businesses must often operate. The third part of
the course incorporates ideas and business strategies from the book Using
the Law for Competitive Advantage. The book, which has been specially created
for EMBA programs, explores how an understanding of law and how our
American legal system works can be helpful for managers to gain a competitive
edge over their competition. Two business scenarios that will be explored
will be employment practices and product development. Lectures will include
substantive tort, contract and employment law principles as they apply to
these two important areas of business management.
In all three areas there will be discussion of the role of ethics and how,
with an understanding of the law, managers will have be able to create both
a legal and ethical environment for the benefit of their major stakeholders.
Course Objectives The purpose of this course is to assist managers
and others with responsible positions in business to identify and think clearly
about legal and ethical issues which confront them in their official roles.
Specific objectives include:
--providing a factual knowledge of the basis and workings of
the U.S. legal and regulatory systems as they apply to the
practice of business.
--helping managers and professionals to recognize the
presence of legal concerns, and the need for appropriate
professional legal advice.
--increasing awareness on the part of managers and other
business professionals of the ethical implications of
their decisions.
--providing a basis, rooted in the views of important
philosophers, for thinking clearly and consistently about
ethical issues as they appear in managerial and
professional work.
--learning to development and apply a business legal plan.
--through the use of an actual case (A Civil Action), an insight in how
complex
litigation works applying both substantive and procedural laws.
Attainment of these objectives, and other objectives, will be evaluated
through participation in classroom discussions, exams and a paper/presentation.
Course Materials
There are three required books:
A Civil Action, by Jonathon Harr
Using the Law for Competitive Advantage, by George J. Siedel.
Law, Regulation and Ethics, by Joseph Gilbert and Robert Aalberts.
Grading The semester grade will be based on the following components:
Final Exam 35%
Term Paper 35%
Participation 30%
Instruction on Term Paper
Students will write a paper applying the 4 steps presented in the “The Manager’s
Legal Plan” detailed on pages 20-25 in the book Using the Law for Competitive
Advantage. Students will be asked to form on their own a three person group
and compose and present to the class their work product. The paper will be
based on a legal problem. Each group will also make a short presentation to
the class followed by class discussion of the paper in the last two days of
class. More details will be provided on the first day.
Note on Participation
Active participation in the class requires that you be present, take part
class discussions, and add to both the content and the quality of these discussions.
EMBA courses are greatly enriched by the shared experiences and insights of
the class members: this is the objective of the participation portion of
the grade. Much of the learning in this course will occur during class
lectures and discussions.
Other Information
--Smoking is not allowed in the classroom.
--Audio recording of class sessions should be discussed with the professor
in advance.
--Students who wish to bring a visitor to class should discuss this with
the professor in advance.
THIS SYLLABUS IS A GUIDE, NOT A CONTRACT. IT MAY BE REVISED IF IT
SEEMS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CLASS TO DO SO. STUDENTS WILL BE
NOTIFIED PROMPTLY OF ANY REVISIONS.
Class Schedule
EMBA 702: Law, Regulation, and Ethical Issues
July-September 2006
Fri. July 21: Introduction; Review
of Syllabus.
Three views of ethics: Utilitarianism, Rights and
Duties, Fairness and Justice.
Reading Assignment: pp.22-98.
Sat. July 22: Comparative
Legal Systems-Common Law and Civil Law.
Reading Assignment: pp. 1-12; 13-21.
Fri. Aug. 4: Comparative Legal
Systems-Common Law and Civil Law
Reading Assignment: pp. 13-21 (re-read for class).
A Civil Action: Read “Boston: July 1986 through “Rule 11.”
Sat. Aug. 5: A Civil Action: Read “Discovery through “Billion-Dollar
Charlie.” Using the Law: Read Chapter 1 (pp.1-28) “Seizing Competitive Advantage:
A Legal Plan for Managers.”
Fri. Aug. 18: A Civil Action: Read
“Facher’s Plea through “The Vigil.”
Using the Law: Read Chapter 2 (pp. 29-56). “Meet Your Customer Needs” Moving
from Product Liability to Product Innovation.”
Sat. Aug. 19: A Civil Action: Read “The Negotiation” through
“Blindman’s Buff” and “The Afterword.”
Using the Law: Read Chapter 3 (pp. 57-99) Create Competitive Advantage Through
Your Employees.”
Presentations of Manager’s Legal Plan
Fri. Sept. 1: Presentations continued.
Final Exam
|
Sample Test Questions Given in MBA class in prior Semesters
Fall 2002
Doug MacKenzie, an American lawyer in Seattle, and Uta Schmidt, a lawyer
in Berlin, are both sitting in their respective offices pondering a similar
legal problem. MacKenzie's American client and Schmidt's German client both
signed contracts with parties from their own countries. In both cases, their
clients' suffered loses. Both clients feel that they've been legally wronged
and are seeking to sue the party that they feel did this to them.
Explain first what sources of law MacKenzie must look at and analyze
when he researches his case and then explain to his client its chances of
prevailing or not in a lawsuit in the American (common law) legal system
between two American parties.
Next, explain what Schmidt must likewise do when she researches her
case and what she will explain to her client about its chances of prevailing
or not in a German (civil law) legal system between two German parties.
To maximize your score, assume scenarios in which there may or may not be
law that directly addresses this issue and how the attorneys will deal with
this.
Sample Mid-Semester Exam Question, Fall-2001
William Cheeseman, one of the attorneys representing W.R. Grace in the book
"A Civil Action" viewed himself as an aggressive litigator who specialized
in pretrial procedures. Discuss some of the pretrial actions Cheeseman
pursued in an attempt to either end the lawsuit before trial or force the
plaintiffs to settle.
MBA 706 Sample Ethics Mid-Semester Exam Question
If the case had gone the other way and the defendant Grace had not settled,
Schlichtmann’s partners would have lost their houses and suppliers of services
to Schlichtmann’s firm would have gone unpaid. Was it moral for Jan
Schlichtmann to spend as much borrowed money as he did pursuing this case?
Why or why not? Use each of the three approaches to ethics to answer
this question
|